• Services
    • Catastrophic Personal Injury
    • Companies & Businesses
    • Commercial Property
    • Divorce & Family
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Personal Wealth
    • Property Development
    • Residential Property
  • Sectors
    • CleanTech
    • AgriTech
    • Charities
    • Education
    • Farms & Estates
    • Leisure
    • Medical, Dental & Veterinary
    • Public Sector
    • Renewable Energy
  • Our People
  • Join us
  • About
  • Contact
  • Services
    • Catastrophic Personal Injury
    • Companies & Businesses
    • Commercial Property
    • Divorce & Family
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Personal Wealth
    • Property Development
    • Residential Property
  • Sectors
    • CleanTech
    • AgriTech
    • Charities
    • Education
    • Farms & Estates
    • Leisure
    • Medical, Dental & Veterinary
    • Public Sector
    • Renewable Energy
  • Our People
  • Join us
  • About
  • Contact
01223 417200
Home Knowledge Base Commercial Property Landlords: Beware of Unreasonable Demands

Landlords: Beware of Unreasonable Demands

Tenants’ circumstances change.  Sometimes this means that a tenant will want permission to assign their lease.  When can a landlord reasonably refuse a tenant’s request?

This was the question before the court in No.1 West India Quay (Residential) Ltd v East Tower Apartments Ltd [2016] EWHC 2438 (Ch). The court held that one of the three conditions for assignment set by West India (the Landlord) was so unreasonable that the Landlord had breached its obligations to East Tower (the Tenant) under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1988.

Facts of the case
The Tenant was the lessee of several apartments in a building owned by the Landlord in Canary Wharf. The Tenant decided to sell its apartments. Under the terms of the lease, the Tenant was required to obtain the consent of the Landlord to any assignment. The Landlord was not to unreasonably withhold its consent.

The Landlord granted consent to a number of the Tenant’s requests for sales. However, relations between the Landlord and the Tenant soured. When the Tenant applied for consent to assign the lease of two additional apartments, the Landlord set the following three conditions for assignment, the Tenant must:

  • pay an assignment consideration fee of £1600 plus VAT;
  • pay an apartment inspection fee and allow the apartments to be inspected; and
  • provide bank references from any potential assignees.

After a failure to agree, the Landlord refused to grant consent.

Burden is on Landlord to show refusal is reasonable
The Act requires landlords to grant consent within a reasonable period of time once requested. Crucially, the Act places the burden of proof on the landlord to show the reasonableness of any refusal to grant consent. But how reasonable does a landlord have to be?

This is not an easy question. For the court of first instance, the request for bank references was unreasonable in view of, amongst other things, the high price to be paid by the assignees for the apartments being indicative of their financial position. However, the court of appeal disagreed. The request for bank details could be justified given the level of likely service charges. The court also held that the Landlord had a right to inspect the property and the Tenant had undertaken to pay the Landlord’s fees connected to a consent application.

Elizabeth Deyong Property Partner Barr EllisonFor the court of appeal, the main issue was the Landlord’s request for payment of a £1600 fee to even consider the application. This was so unreasonable as to override the other two, potentially reasonable, conditions. As the court of first instance had assessed, a fee of £350 might have been more accurate.

Common sense prevails
This case makes it clear that if there are expenses involved in any potential assignment and the landlord states that reimbursement is a precondition for the assignment, then these should be genuine and clearly quantifiable.  Disingenuous charges, for example, a charge set to merely consider an assignment application, will likely be considered unreasonable by the courts.  Common sense prevails.

For more information please contact Elizabeth Deyong (email: e.deyong@barrellison.co.uk) (telephone: 01223 417 267).

Disclaimer: While we do all that is possible in terms of ensuring its accuracy, this blog contains general information only. Nothing in these pages constitutes legal advice. You need to consult a suitably qualified lawyer from the firm on any specific legal problem or matter.

More Commercial Property Articles

Turnover rent – trends and head scratcher moments!

Turnover rent – trends and head scratcher moments!

There has been a marked increase in turnover provisions creeping into commercial leases, ranging from the fairly standard turnover percentage payment on top of a base rent to a much more complex beast that can [...]

1 Apr 2021
Read full article
Turnover rents – it’s time to break a leg!

Turnover rents – it’s time to break a leg!

The mantra underpinning the landlord and tenant relationship since the pandemic has been collaboration and flexibility – this just so happens to be two of the core characteristics of a turnover rent

12 Jan 2021
Read full article
Recovery of Possession from Residential Tenants

Recovery of Possession from Residential Tenants

Recovery of Possession: the government is keen to afford residential tenants greater security and the increasing obstacles to service of a Section 21 Notice appear directed at this.

15 Sep 2020
Read full article
Unlocking Value: Sales and Leasebacks

Unlocking Value: Sales and Leasebacks

Advice on the legal structure of sale and leaseback transactions which would allow businesses to remain in occupation of their current operating sites while raising much needed cash in the short term.

8 Jul 2020
Read full article
Commercial Leases: Gearing up as we Emerge from the Pandemic

Commercial Leases: Gearing up as we Emerge from the Pandemic

If you are considering lease variations, get in touch to talk through how these can best done most effectively.

23 Apr 2020
Read full article
Buying or Selling Land? Instruct Your Solicitor Carefully

Buying or Selling Land? Instruct Your Solicitor Carefully

This case demonstrates the impact of technology on practices that have developed prior to that technology.

29 Jan 2020
Read full article
Fixtures and Chattels: Be Clear or Be Aware

Fixtures and Chattels: Be Clear or Be Aware

The case provides a lesson to all involved in the sale/purchase of a property. Make it clear, from the outset, both in negotiations and in the contract, what is included in the sale and [...]

22 Oct 2019
Read full article
Brexit not frustrating leases … yet

Brexit not frustrating leases … yet

The High Court has granted the European Medicines Agency the right to appeal its decision that its Canary Wharf lease has not been frustrated by Brexit.

23 Jul 2019
Read full article
Sober Reading for Landowner Victims of Waste Dumping

Sober Reading for Landowner Victims of Waste Dumping

The background to this case provides sober reading for any landowners of vacant sites. In this instance, around 2000 tonnes of waste including food and medical waste was deposited on Newark’s vacant land without [...]

24 Jun 2019
Read full article
Mortgage Default: Who May Buy the Property?

Mortgage Default: Who May Buy the Property?

Anybody entrusted with selling property on the behalf of a lender can take comfort in the robust approach shown by the Court.

23 May 2019
Read full article
Posted on 7 Sep 2018

Other Articles

  • Commercial Property
    • Landlord & Tenant
  • Community
  • Contested Wills Probate
  • Divorce & Family Breakdown
    • Alternatives to Court
    • Child Arrangements
    • Cohabitation Agreements
    • Collaborative Divorce
    • Divorce Finances
    • Nuptial Agreements
  • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Debt Recovery
    • Landlord & Tenant Disputes
    • Property & Boundary Disputes
  • Personal Injury
  • Property Development
  • Residential Conveyancing
  • Wills, Probate, Tax & Trusts
Legals
  • Cookies
  • Cyber Fraud
  • Disclaimer & Privacy Policy
  • GDPR
  • Gender Pay Report
  • Professional Status & Insurance
  • Terms of Service
  • Workforce Diversity Data
Where to find us
Parkside Office

39 Parkside
Parker's Piece
Cambridge
CB1 1PN

01223 417200

enquiry@barrellison.co.uk

Addenbrooke's Office

PO Box 196
The Concourse
Addenbrooke’s Hospital
Hills Road, Cambridge, CB2 0QQ

01223 411315

enquiry@barrellison.co.uk

Copyright Barr Ellison LLP - all rights reserved